Skip to main content

2027 PD sorted for your team

Keep educator wellbeing at the top of the agenda, with practical workshops that make space for the people behind the work.

Explore 2027 workshopsExplore 2027 workshops

The Educators Well logo
Wellbeing

What do you value as making a good educator?

By Rachel Smith · 27 September 2026 · 11 min read

What actually makes someone a good educator? Beyond résumés, references, beautiful environments and visible skills, perhaps we need to look more closely at who educators are, what they value and what helps them thrive.

What do you value as making a good educator?

I came across a post from an educator recently asking whether being a good educator depends on how good you are at art and craft. They felt that in their service, the educators who were really good at creative experiences, art and displays seemed to receive more recognition than educators whose strengths were things like supervision, managing a room, supporting challenging behaviour, interacting with children and keeping them safe.

My immediate thought was no. Of course being good at art and craft doesn’t make you a good educator. But then I kept thinking about it, because I don’t actually think this is a conversation about art and craft at all. I think the bigger question is, what do we value as making a good educator? And perhaps before we can answer that, we need to think about who we actually are as educators.

If you caught my webinar last week, you might remember an activity we did around the words “I am”. Who are you? As educators, we can get so caught up in what we do that being an educator almost becomes who we are. But I am not only an educator. I am Rachel. I am a Mum, a Wife, a TBI survivor, a business owner, a friend, a mentor, a learner and so much more. All of those parts of me have shaped the person I am, and whether I consciously realise it or not, they have also shaped the educator I have been.

So maybe we need to take that same thinking into our professional identity. Who are you as an educator? Not just what do you do or what are you good at, but what do you value? What do you believe about children? What matters to you? What is your philosophy? Because those things influence our practice far more than I think we sometimes realise.

I was visiting a service recently that was almost completely concrete and artificial grass outdoors. They had actually been trying to make some significant improvements to the environment and had started creating small garden areas over the concrete. They were putting genuine effort into it, but couldn’t work out why they were struggling to keep their plants alive.

For me, being in that environment was hard. It is so far removed from my own philosophy of what I value in children’s environments. I value nature. I value children having access to dirt, grass, plants, trees and outdoor spaces that feel alive. I know how much environment affects me, and I think sometimes we forget that when we talk about children too.

We see children having big behaviours when they have been cooped up inside or haven’t had the opportunity to move, explore or regulate in an environment that meets their needs. We consider whether they need fresh air, movement, sensory experiences or simply more space. We look at what is happening around the child and ask whether the environment might be contributing to what we are seeing.

But the same thing applies to us.

Our environment affects us. Our relationships affect us. The culture around us, the expectations placed on us, and the way we are spoken to, supported, trusted and valued all affect how we show up. Maybe sometimes what we describe as an educator who “isn’t working out” is actually an educator who isn’t working well in that environment.

There is a difference.

A child may thrive in one environment and struggle in another, and an educator can too. I know I would struggle working every day in an environment completely disconnected from some of the things I value deeply in early childhood. Another educator might walk into exactly the same service and absolutely love it. That doesn’t automatically make either of us a better educator. It means we are different people, bringing different experiences, strengths, beliefs and values with us.

I think this is where the idea of someone being a “good fit” becomes really interesting. Sometimes an educator and a service simply don’t mesh. Their philosophies may be different. Their communication styles might be different. Their expectations, approaches to children, environments, leadership or teamwork may be different. Sometimes the service isn’t right for the educator, and sometimes the educator isn’t right for the service. That doesn’t automatically make either one bad, and it certainly shouldn’t mean the educator suddenly has less value.

Maybe instead of immediately asking, “What’s wrong with this educator?”, we need to become a little more curious. What would help this educator thrive here? Is there something they need to learn? Is there mentoring they haven’t received? Is there a strength we haven’t recognised because we have been too focused on what they aren’t doing well? Is there something about the environment, culture or leadership that is making it harder for them to do their best work?

Keep reading with a free account

Blog reading is free. No payment or subscription is needed.

  • educator wellbeing
  • educator identity
  • educator philosophy
  • professional philosophy
  • early childhood educators
  • educator values
  • professional growth
  • reflective practice
  • educator strengths
  • workplace culture
  • educator development
  • early childhood education

Comments

No comments yet. Yours could be the first.

Leave a comment

Comments are read before they appear, so yours won't show up straight away. Your email address is never published.

Stay in the loop

New articles, reflections and practical support for educators, straight to your inbox.